Posted on April 14, 2017
Retro Reaction #52.3 Peter Pan and Facebook Theory
I was going to summarise the differences here between the book and the film. Problem here is I’ve never read the book and assumed them to be broadly the same. I now plan to read the book!
The book is based on the play by J M Barrie. Whilst researching for this article I have found forums of people quite angry about how much the book was changed by the cartoon. Personally I can understand why Disney would want to change a few characters. Tinkerbell and Peter for example would not have been such great money spinners had they remained as self centred as the characters outlined in the book. I must come back to this one once read! However to view a list of changes (and because here at Spaceman we like there are people out there blogging away like us take a look at this url
So what’s left for Reaction this week.. Have I just passed you some further reading and tagged out. No dear readers. We’re going to remember that Disney film, then we are going to look at a certain sad theory that has been going round on Facebook.
Firstly the film. Like last weeks Dumbo will always be remembered for Pink Elephants here it’s Never Smile at a Crocodile. Captain hook is pretty much a comedy bad guy. He makes me wonder why the American’s never got the idea of Panto. I won’t go through the plot of the Disney film, because I’m pretty sure everyone has seen it.
Now the Sad facebook theory. “Peter Pan is an angel who walks children to Heaven. The Children are dead”
Searching around this one is likely untrue. For starters he visits Wendy as an Adult at the end of the book. In the film Mr Darling remembers the Pirate ship from his own childhood. Unless they’re all really dead (and I really don’t think it’s that kind of book) this theory can’t be true.
I think Peter Pan is the spirit of childhood imagination both in the book and in the Disney Film. In the book it ends with the notion that Wendy had a daughter who also visits Neverland, and that this loop continues. Could this be representing the mischievous spirit of childhood. It would explain why both Peter and Tinkerbell are portrayed as mischievous in the Disney film and self centred in the books.
But for an insight into Peter Pan I would recommend the tear jerking film Finding Neverland from 2004, and for an interesting “elseworlds” story set in the Disney continuity there is always Hook a film that’s featured right here at Reaction before..
Until Next Time
Have a Great Dayyyyyyy!!!!!!!