
-
NSMB2: Do the coins still sparkle?

We’re a good few years on from Mario Wii now.
With bills to pay and work to go to, by about 2014 or 2015 I enjoyed browsing through games. Browsing being the key word. Video game purchases were now very much a luxury.
Thankfully, much like when you’re a child, my late Nan would give me money on birthdays. This money wasn’t to go towards bills. No, she wanted to know what you got with it.
After much research, and with Nan’s cash, I managed to pick myself up a 3DS (one of the few purchases I’ve made that’ actually gone up in value). I still have it and, the last time I played it, it still worked. The left thumb protector is a bit loose. I’ve played it to death.
A little older, I went back to a strategy for saving money that had worked in my youth. If there was a console I liked but not as a main console, I stayed a generation behind. That sweet spot meant you could (or used to be able to) clear up at GAME £10 lineup as they cleared shelf space for the next big thing.
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D, Super Mario 3D Land (we will get there), and Yoshi’ Island had all come from this clearance line. That day, with its bright yellow box, New Super Mario Bros. 2 was all mine for a tenner.
The Super Mario Bros. had taken my coins again.
I had read the reviews. Although quite positive, they described it as more of the same. I think that’ fair, but I still had a great time with this one. I really liked that power-up where everything turns to gold. The levels were a lot of fun. I also enjoyed the callbacks to Super Mario Bros. 3 on the NES. The only drawback was that the game looked a lot like the previous two entries in the series.
So before I jump to the conclusion that this title was more of the same, let’ look at my most-played games on the 3DS. Mario is at the top, followed closely by Ocarina of Time. But it’ not the New Super Mario Bros. series that claims the top spot. It’ Super Mario 3D Land, a game that I would argue borrows heavily from NSMB.
The 3DS had a 2D Mario and a 3D Mario in the style of a 2D Mario on the same platform. As good as NSMB2 is (and I still argue that it is), Super Mario 3D Land was, for me, the better game. It didn’t sell as well as NSMB2, perhaps in part because of that Mario Bros. name. The takeaway, though, is that 3DS owners had the choice of more than one Mario platformer.
I still loved the NSMB series. But I admit it had gone from a must-buy to a “I’ll have that when the price drops” purchase. A sign of Mario fatigue, perhaps.
But perhaps more a matter of circumstance. My habit of following the series later than release would continue with New Super Mario Bros. U.
-
NSMB Wii: The Mushroom Kingdom Will Always Need Saving

The Nintendo Wii was the first delivery to my first home. A brand-new console. Mario had indeed taken my coins (but not given me a life).
Looking back, it has been an incredibly well-used purchase. Years later, I upgraded to the Wii U, but as I write this, the games are being moved into the gaming room the nephews use. Wii Sports, particularly its bowling mode, remains a room-pleaser even today.
The Mii characters may have changed over the years. The fun has not.
Then we get New Super Mario Bros. Wii. This one took everything that the Nintendo DS game did and made it better. The level design is pure Nintendo. We keep that sense of fun without making things too challenging. On a single-player playthrough, it’s still a strong entry in the New Super Mario Bros. series.
But more importantly, I think, the Wii version is multiplayer.
Yes, I would occasionally have fun with my housemates, my brother, and his friends on this. It was a very good icebreaker. Friends who were naturally shy would come out of themselves during a game of Mario.
It was later that I got the most fun out of this one. When you dig it out of the drawer for the under-10s, New Super Mario Bros. Wii is a killer game.
Some of its visuals were even used in the recent Mario film. My nephew kept nudging me in the cinema to say, “I killed you there. And there.”
My oldest nephew has been my Player 2 since he could waddle across the street.
Sometimes life, time, and circumstances lead to us having a smaller role in others’ lives than we once had. But no matter how old he’s gotten, and no matter how little time there seems to be, there is a constant.
The Mushroom Kingdom will always need saving.
-
NSMB How Mario took my coins again

Its 2006. The circumstances are just right for the plumbers to return.
The Nintendo DS would see its user base top 150 million. By contrast, the Switch has only recently done that. The DS was everywhere.
The commercial for New Super Mario Bros (NSMB) purposefully used the music from the original Super Mario Bros on the NES. The intention was clear. This is the same series. A clear trade in nostalgia.
I don’t use the term “must buy” or “day one purchase” very often. Because I’m not rich, not by a long shot. Although I was working in the early 00s, I was also new to things like paying my own bills and feeding myself. My brother and I had moved in together. There was very little money.
But I did buy it. Of course I did.
I was in good company too. New Super Mario Bros on the DS is surpassed in sales only by the original Super Mario Bros on the NES.
Much as I love that the original is still the best-selling Mario platformer, you can’t really discount that it was a pack-in title for the hugely popular NES.
Was the game itself any good? For me, yes. But you’re going to get that same answer for most of the series.
The thing that comes to mind when remembering or replaying NSMB is just how much fun the game is.
The enemies dance to the very catchy music. The world is colourful and the levels are filled with that Nintendo charm. Those flagpoles from the original? They’re back.
The levels are filled with secrets. NSMB is how your brain thinks SMB and the Mushroom Kingdom always were.
This is pretty much a requel.
But it isn’t SMB, and that’s fine. It’s easier than those NES games we all loved. I don’t see this as a negative. It’s actually something I like about the NSMB series.
You see, that accessibility allows younger players to get far into the game, even beat it. If, however, you want to get the most out of the game, that requires collecting 90 Star Coins to unlock the final world.
There’s more play value here than you might imagine if you chase that completion goal.
I never did. I was happy with the roughly eight or nine-hour leisurely playthrough.
For me, it was a game that made me grin pretty much all the way through.
Another big development from Nintendo at the time. I remember a call from a friend.
“Have you seen what Nintendo are doing? Their next console is going back to a simple two buttons. It’s going to be cheaper than the Xbox or PlayStation. They’re just going back to making a fun console.”
I had just signed for my house. Remember my “no day one” rule? I caved and pre-ordered anyway.
I’m glad I did because for a while after launch the Wii was sold out. A variation of that console sits under my TV now, almost 20 years later.
It would go on to outsell Sony’s PlayStation 3 and Microsoft’s Xbox 360.
Nintendo had struck gold again, and I had the console where I would see first-hand the next generation being introduced to the NSMB series with New Super Mario Bros Wii.
-
Wario: Nintendo’s Experimental Child

It’s 1989. Super Mario mania is running wild on the back of the Super Mario Bros. series on the NES. Nintendo launches their Game Boy and it has a Super Mario game.
Super Mario Land was the first main Mario title not designed by Shigeru Miyamoto. It showed.
That’s not to say it was a bad game. Reactions vary. We’ll get to the Game Boy later.
The point is that things were different on handheld. The rules of the console series didn’t have to apply. Yes, Mario jumped on the heads of baddies, but he also had his own submarine and spaceship. The princess was called Daisy, not Peach. Tatanga, an alien, was the main bad guy, not Bowser.
The handheld series was able to deviate, and with Super Mario Land 2 we got Mario’s frenemy. Evil Mario, known as Wario. The character has been a mainstay in the Nintendo line-up ever since.
The character made that much of an impression that he became the focus of the Mario Land series. So much so that the next sequel was Wario Land: Super Mario Land 3. Wario Land got three sequels: Wario Land 2 (Game Boy, 1998), Wario Land 3 (Game Boy Color, 2000), and Wario Land 4 (Game Boy Advance, 2001).
Each Wario Land brought with it a new gimmick, be that Metroidvania-style exploration or puzzles where you had to transform into different forms. But at their core, these were a set of Nintendo-published 2D platform games, using handheld systems as their platform of choice.
Wario has always felt like Nintendo’s “test the water” character.
I admit that at this point I too had followed the 3D wave of gaming. I was playing Ridge Racer and Time Crisis. My GameCube had Resident Evil, Mario Sunshine and Luigi’s Mansion. I only discovered that Nintendo’s 2D platforming tradition had continued later on when these titles became available on the Nintendo eShop.
It raises the question: would a 2D platformer have sold well during that era? There were some good ones, as I recall, over on Sony’s PlayStation. Rayman and Earthworm Jim 2 spring to mind.
Would I have paid full price for a 2D platform game in the early 2000s? I honestly couldn’t answer that.
But the handheld market was evolving too. Nintendo made the decision to end the long-running Game Boy line of consoles, launching what would become the best-selling handheld console family of all time.
Everyone had a Nintendo DS. Your elderly aunt had a DS. Your grandad had a DS. I can’t understate how massive the Nintendo DS and its brain-training craze became.
With such a big player base, the conditions were just right for Nintendo to chase those golden coins again with their biggest attraction. Wario was stood aside, the brothers were back.
Next time, we look at the games themselves.
-
Hooked on the Brothers: Mario Advance

It’s the early 00s and the world is now obsessed with 3D gaming. The Sega Saturn had been built more around 2D, and it had at least commercially been seen as a failure. Sony’s PlayStation had won out in the console wars. Microsoft were about to enter the console market with their Xbox. The first one. Not to be confused with Xbox One (never got why they did that). This was the original Xbox. Never owned one, but the ones I saw? Those things were big.
The big games were Metal Gear Solid 2 and Grand Theft Auto III. Games had made the jump to 3D. The gaming landscape was settling into a status quo still recognised today.
The era of the mascot platformer had passed, mostly. The pixel art of 2D gaming was seen as old now. Everyone wanted 3D and arcade-perfect graphics.
That’s what was going on with the home consoles. The handhelds, however, were another story. The Game Boy Advance was Nintendo’s next version of the Game Boy, and an upgrade to something approaching Super Nintendo quality. A 16-bit system existed with a user base estimated at around 81 million.
But rather than make 2D platform games for their handheld, Nintendo looked to their past. Remember how the SNES had Mario All-Stars and Super Mario World? Both had already been remade for 16-bit hardware. Nintendo decided to re-release these games as the Super Mario Advance series.
I remember having some relations over from the USA, and they were glued to their portable Nintendos. I assume they had made quite a lot of progress on the plane. When I glanced over their shoulder, I was delighted to see they were playing a Mario game. Throwing turnips at bad guys in a game I called Super Mario Bros. 2, but they called Super Mario Advance.
Nintendo had got another generation into Super Mario games by re-releasing what they already had.
It worked. Outside of the Pokémon series, which became massive, the Super Mario Advance series was among the most successful on the GBA. With the Game Boy Color receiving a port of the original Super Mario Bros. (which included The Lost Levels as a bonus), the entire Super Mario Bros. back catalogue never really went away.
While the massive 3D games of the time were hitting larger TVs, Super Mario remained big on the little screen.
The Mario Advance series saw to it that another generation grew up with Mario.
The re-releases worked, and it was great to see another generation “Hooked on the Brothers”. But there were no new adventures.
Mario, though, has a frenemy. Evil Mario, known to gamers as Wario. After being defeated by Mario in Super Mario Land 2, he took that series for himself as Wario Land. Wario seems to be Nintendo’s go-to character for testing the waters. (I’m looking at you, WarioWare.)
To tell the story of how we get to New Super Mario Bros., we need to go back to Wario Land.
-
The Story of the Mario Bros 2006 Requel

It has been almost 20 years since Nintendo rebooted the 2D Super Mario Bros. franchise.
Let that sink in for a moment. In around three months from now, New Super Mario Bros. will be as old as Super Mario Bros. was when it first came out.
Over at Never-ending 80s, we looked at defending the legacy sequel. Here, Nintendo, the most recognised brand in all of gaming, did its own legacy sequel to the Super Mario Bros. franchise.
You see, the name was New Super Mario Bros., not Super Mario Bros. 5 (with Super Mario World technically being the fourth main entry on the SNES). It was not a continuation as such. So, legacy sequel?
Sort of.
It’s important to point out that Mario had never gone away. The “mainline” Mario games had switched to 3D with the well-received Super Mario 64 for the N64 back in 1997 (for us in the UK).
These 3D games had been massively successful overall, and Super Mario Galaxy is a darn good reason to find and power on a Nintendo Wii today. Retro Reaction will get to those in time, too.
This was designed to satisfy those older fans. A throwback to when Mario was a simple case of getting Jumpman to the far right of the screen. A world of flagpoles, fireballs and, erm, dancing Goombas.
Over the next few blogs, we’re going to be looking at Nintendo’s rebooted New Super Mario Bros. series, at a time when Nintendo wasn’t really focusing on 2D games.
We will see how they tested the waters with 2D gaming through a lesser-known character from the Mario universe, and how the 2D games would eventually come full circle, feeding ideas back into the 3D ones.
New Super Mario Bros. arrived in a wave of nostalgic glory. But by 2012, Nintendo was being accused of replaying the same notes one too many times.
It’s requel month at Retro Reaction. As Mario himself would say, “Let’s-a go!”
-
Ranking Elm Street: Nightmare on Elm Street
After that viewing of Part 3 and needing to be walked home despite being at secondary school, those words from my friends rang true:
“If you thought that was scary, you should see Freddy 1.”
We did indeed watch “Freddy 1”, more well known of course as A Nightmare on Elm Street.
This film hits different. It opens with a horror segment — a teen running through a nightmare landscape. You automatically settle in, assuming we’re following our protagonist Tina… only for her to be killed in the first few minutes.
The message is clear: no one is safe.
What the film does next is build tension absolutely perfectly. We meet Nancy and her friends. The adults — always a step behind in horror — have Tina’s boyfriend down as her killer. As the characters talk about their nightmares featuring the same “creep”, we know that night has to come. It’s this cycle that ramps up the tension massively. You know, because it’s universal, that they will have to fall asleep.
Unlike the other films, Freddy is on screen here for a grand total of seven minutes. This monster makes the version in the sequels look like a parody. His story is told through the other characters, and that is so much scarier. Proof, I think, that what you don’t see can be scarier than what you do.
But those story beats we do get… wow. One line on first watch from Nancy’s drunk mother: “He’s dead, Nan. He can’t get you. Mommy killed him.”
In this ghost story, the spectre, demon, or whatever Freddy is has the children paying for their parents’ sins. This is why none of the adults on Elm Street believe the kids.
Then there’s the ending. Bob Shaye, the producer, wanted to keep Freddy “alive”, seeing the potential in Elm Street as a franchise (he was right). Wes described a different ending — one that is actually a much better fit for the film (he was also right).
After pulling Freddy’s hat from her dream, Nancy realises she can bring Freddy back into the real world where he can be hurt. Today we’re used to seeing characters like Nancy in horror — but back in ’84, girls in these films usually did a lot of running and screaming. This was wonderfully against the norm.
Towards the end she faces Freddy and tells him: “I want my mother and friends again. I take back every bit of energy I gave you. You’re nothing. You’re sh*t.”
With that, Freddy is gone.
In Wes’s proposed ending, this wasn’t undone. Nancy goes to school the next day, her friends still alive.
The ending we got… well, you’ve likely seen it. The car has Freddy colours, and he drags Nancy’s mum through the door. The seeds of MTV Freddy are planted right there.
But imagine for a moment that Nancy’s powerful victory was left to stand. That Wes Craven’s ending was the one we got. A Nightmare on Elm Street would be a one‑and‑done masterpiece.
As it is, though, it’s still a masterclass in tension and a perfect Halloween watch.
Had Wes got his way, would I have watched Part 3 at my friend’s house? Would my friends even know who Freddy Krueger was? Would I be writing this blog to you all on Hallows’ Eve?
-
Ranking Elm Street: The Dream Child

Number 4: Nightmare on Elm Street Part 5: The Dream Child
We’ve reached one of the more difficult parts of the countdown. There’s a strong argument that Part 4 could sit in this spot. The Dream Child is often seen toward the back end of the Nightmare series, and there are downsides to it — plenty of them.
Here’s my reasoning. Of the two movies where our Dream Master Alice defeats Freddy, this is the one that doesn’t dismantle the previous film in the first twenty minutes. Much like The Dream Master, it’s unmistakably 80s in tone and effects. But more importantly, it tries something different with the franchise this far in. Probably just a personal opinion, but I found the question of whether unborn babies dream interesting enough to carry the story.
We also build on some of the lore introduced in The Dream Warriors: Krueger being the son of a nun who was abused in an asylum. The doors were locked, the guards left for a few days — unlikely, yes, but it’s a ghost story. Amanda Krueger first appeared under the alias Sister Mary in Dream Warriors, and in The Dream Child she has powers to haunt and stop Freddy… at least until Part 6.
We get another round of very 80s deaths. A character is killed inside a comic book. But Freddy retains a darker edge not seen for a few films at this point. The Amanda Krueger ghost story and some more unsettling kills alongside it give the film a tone shift away from the “MTV Freddy,” though not completely.
It’s mixed. The latter half of Part 4 is probably stronger. But for me, the different premise and the change in tone just edge it over Part 5.
And now we’re heading into the top three — the films with the most involvement from series creator Wes Craven. The three that most people think of when they look back on A Nightmare on Elm Street.
Next time, we look at the film that took the whole saga and turned it on its head. An influential entry with DNA that runs through so much of modern horror. I’ll see you in the next one.
