
Going back to that conversation.
“I think you don’t like it because it’s a greatest hits movie, a goodbye.”
There was a silence, then an admission.
“You’re right.”
That is what a requel faces. The pre-existing idea that it’s not as good as the original.
I have nostalgia for Beetlejuice. In our household, those BBFC certificates mattered. It’s why Adam West was my Batman until the early 1990s. That 15 certificate. Yes, in the UK, Batman ’89 received a 15 certificate.
Incidentally, since 12A became a thing, both films have been reclassified.
Beetlejuice, though, I remember my Dad saying, “Yeah, go on then.”
I now don’t think the content of Beetlejuice was any worse than Batman ’89. My Dad just had little tolerance for superheroes and had probably checked over Beetlejuice because it fell into the comedy category. Either way, I saw it on TV and we recorded it onto VHS. It was one of those movies.
I know that, to the friend I was talking with, the 1988 original was perfect.
Being honest, I always found it fun but a bit chaotic. It was a film I liked nonetheless. A film we watched more than once.
The sequel I enjoyed. I think equally as much. The Bob gags were good. (My car was actually named Bob because he came from a company called Big Bob’s Motors, not after the character.) I liked that Catherine O’Hara’s character got a lot to do in this one and, like Ghostbusters: Afterlife before it, the younger cast are just as good as their predecessors. I also like that requel vibe of passing the torch. Repeating a point from a few weeks ago: they’re not our toys anymore.
That’s not to say this film is any less Beetlejuice being Beetlejuice.
There are a few things, though, where I had to concede they didn’t quite tally, and this is maybe my memory and that darn nostalgia being a tad biased again.
When we left strange and unusual Lydia, she had come home from school and was left dancing with ghosts, quite literally. She had been the strongest character in that first film, often being the smartest person in a room full of eccentric adults.
By 2024, she is begging for pills to make the ghosts go away and trapped in an exploitative relationship with a self-help guru named Rory. What happened to the perfectly capable strange and unusual character from 1988?
Here lies a problem with the requel. It’s going to undo those endings from films of long ago, even if those endings felt perfect.
I gave this character turn a lot of thought. I wondered: was this just a way of getting the plot from A to B? There were notable characters not returning, and we got a lot of great gags out of the Rory and Lydia relationship. Or is Tim Burton suggesting that no matter how unique we think we are when we’re younger, we eventually become our parents?
Would Lydia have been as absent to her daughter as her family were to her in that first film?
I have to think it’s intentional.
There’s dialogue from Delia that suggests as much:
“Stop torturing your mother. I know I usually find it funny, and only fair after the way she treated me when she was your age.”
The plot now follows Lydia’s daughter, Astrid, a character not far removed from Lydia in 1988.
I think Burton is trying to show how family histories can circle back on themselves.
That’s the ultimate hope of a requel, though, isn’t it? How many kids are going to see this like I did the original back in the day? Today, with so much at their fingertips, who knows? They might just go back and watch that 1988 film.
More young people appreciating old movies.
I’m fully on board with that.
